Guardian Trial riddles and answers
Each Guardian of the Keepsake Sea sets a Trial: a list of riddles that are really ordinary chores. Discovery needs 4 of 7, Resilience 8 of 17 and Expression 8 of 15 before the story moves on; finishing every riddle earns a merfolk fin.
Open the trials from the Dreamlight menu (Guardian's Trials tab, key U on PC); in the Keepsake Sea they replace your Dreamlight Duties. The game pins one riddle to the screen at a time, so the table below is the whole list at once, with the quickest picks marked. The Trial of Discovery is answered in full for free; the Resilience and Expression answers are in the $2.99 Tracker Pass.
| Trial | Biome | To pass | All riddles earn |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trial of Discovery | Shipwreck Shores | 4 of 7 | Horizontal Algae merfolk fin |
| Trial of Resilience | Shipwreck Shores | 8 of 17 | Vertical Starry Shark merfolk fin |
| Trial of Expression | Candy Cove | 8 of 15 | Manta Ray merfolk fin |
| Trial of Boldness | Kingdom of Oublié | not confirmed | Ruffled merfolk fin |
A fifth Guardian, Belief, appears at the very end of the story; her riddles have not been published yet.
Guardian of Discovery: Trial of Discovery
- Grotto
- Grotto of Discovery: the cave with the giant mermaid statue on the east (right-hand) side of the Barnacle Bay beach, Shipwreck Shores
- Opens
- During The Four Guardians, after you set the Bottled Binoculars (reward from Sunken Echo: The Binoculars) on the empty far-right pedestal under the statue. Riddles live in Dreamlight menu > Guardian's Trials (U on PC). Once passed, talk to the Guardian in her grotto to move the story on (she hands you the treasure map).
- To pass
- 4 of 7 riddles
- All riddles
- Horizontal Algae merfolk fin (finish all 7, then press Claim at the end of the trial gauge)
Fastest way to pass: the 4 riddles marked quick need no growing, no rare ingredients and no friendship grind, so you can clear them in one visit. Hangouts run on a timer: start one first and do the rest while it counts.
| Riddle as written | Needed | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Use your Dreamlight Magic on some tricky Cursed Anemone | 5 | Walk up to Cursed Anemones around Barnacle Bay and choose Remove. They respawn, so clearing some before the trial opened does not lock you out. |
| Put your Royal Pickaxe to use in Barnacle Bay | 5 | Mine any 5 rock spots inside Barnacle Bay. |
| Use your Shovel and plant some seeds quick | 5 | Plant any 5 seeds anywhere; base-game seeds count and nothing has to grow. Goofy's Stall in Barnacle Bay (free to repair) sells Dreamlight Avocado and Sweet Heart of Palm seeds. |
| Use a mechanical eye to capture an image of a Guardian in her grotto quick | 1 | Open the camera inside the grotto and take one shot with the Guardian of Discovery statue in frame. |
| Haul up treasures from the waters around Barnacle Bay | 5 | Fish 5 times in Barnacle Bay; any catch counts. Quickest: Sea-Comb through ripples in merfolk form. |
| Decorate in Barnacle Bay by placing the Cooking Station given to you by a clever cartographer quick | 1 | In Furniture mode, place the Submarine Cooking Station Milo gave you (end of A Kingdom Across the Sea) anywhere in Barnacle Bay. |
| Decorate in Barnacle Bay by placing the Crafting Station given to you by an ex-plumber quick | 1 | In Furniture mode, place Milo's Cartographer's Crafting Station anywhere in Barnacle Bay. |
Guardian of Resilience: Trial of Resilience
- Grotto
- Grotto of Resilience, on the Guardian's own island off Shipwreck Shores. You can only reach it by ship: ring the bell on the Galleon Gulf dock.
- Opens
- End of The Enchanted Ship: sail there with Jack Sparrow at the Bow and put your three Keepsakes on the Altar of Resilience. Passing is the first objective of A Slippery Situation; after passing, talk to her and she opens the gate to Candy Cove.
- To pass
- 8 of 17 riddles
- All riddles
- Vertical Starry Shark merfolk fin (all 17 riddles, then Claim)
Fastest way to pass: the 8 riddles marked quick need no growing, no rare ingredients and no friendship grind, so you can clear them in one visit. Hangouts run on a timer: start one first and do the rest while it counts.
| Riddle as written | Needed | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Take a picture of a very, very big skull somewhere in Shipwreck Shores quick | 1 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Use your pirate ship to scavenge treasures from the waters around Shipwreck Shores quick | 5 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Pop some bubbles beneath the waves quick | 20 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Make the Doubloon Depths feel more like home by decorating beneath the waves quick | 10 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Harvest a colorful fruit with a hard shell from Shipwreck Shores | 10 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Cook a meal fit for a pirate captain | 2 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Mine a very special barnacle from the rocks around Shipwreck Shores quick | 5 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Spend some time with a cartographer and linguist quick | 15 minutes | In the Tracker Pass |
| Spend some time with a dishonest honest pirate captain | 15 minutes | In the Tracker Pass |
| Harvest a red berry from Shipwreck Shores quick | 20 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Rebuild the dockyard trading post in Barnacle Bay | 1 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Restore a place to shop and spend your loot in Peddler's Post | 1 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Restore a place to gather and eat in Peddler's Post | 1 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Serve food to some hungry customers | 5 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Give a pirate captain one of his favorite things | 5 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Befriend a bird with a very big beak in Shipwreck Shores quick | 1 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Reach a triple-level Friendship with a Villager obsessed with Atlantis | Level 3 | In the Tracker Pass |
What each of the 17 riddles of the Trial of Resilience wants. The $2.99 Tracker Pass opens what each of the 32 riddles of the Trials of Resilience and Expression really asks, with the 8 fastest to pass each one marked, the moves for 3 more Sunken Echoes (7 rooms), every step of 8 later story quests, and where and when to find each critter, fish, plant and blueprint in Candy Cove and the Kingdom of Oublié, in one checklist that remembers what you have done.
One payment, no subscription. Card, Apple Pay or Google Pay. Already paid? Open the map and use "Already bought the pass".
Guardian of Expression: Trial of Expression
- Grotto
- Grotto of Expression, on the Guardian's island in Sweetwater Wharf, Candy Cove. Sail there.
- Opens
- End of Captain Hook's narwhal quest (I CaaAAAannn SpeeeaAAAAAAKKkk WWWHHAAAAALEeee!!!): place your three Candy Cove Keepsakes in her grotto. Passing is the first objective of No Pirates Allowed; then talk to her and sail through the tunnel beside her island into the Kingdom of Oublié.
- To pass
- 8 of 15 riddles
- All riddles
- Manta Ray merfolk fin (all 15, then Claim)
Fastest way to pass: the 8 riddles marked quick need no growing, no rare ingredients and no friendship grind, so you can clear them in one visit. Hangouts run on a timer: start one first and do the rest while it counts.
| Riddle as written | Needed | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Get some photographic evidence from Hook's hideout in Candy Cove quick | 1 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Use your Shovel and plant some seeds around Candy Cove quick | 10 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Collect something shiny and round from clamshells in the Dessert Depths quick | 10 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Whip up some Cake Pops | 3 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Express yourself by making Candy Cove feel a little more like home quick | 10 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Use your Pickaxe to find some very delicious rocks quick | 5 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Spend time with a woman from Greek myth quick | 30 minutes | In the Tracker Pass |
| Spend some time with a dishonest honest pirate captain | 30 minutes | In the Tracker Pass |
| Harvest a Sherbet Cane Straw | 10 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Harvest a very sugary berry quick | 20 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Rebuild a very mint-y building in Sweetwater Wharf | 1 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Serve something up to some hungry customers | 8 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Achieve five times the Friendship with an honest dishonest Pirate Captain | Level 5 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Make friends with a flightless bird around Candy Cove quick | 1 | In the Tracker Pass |
| Give Wonder Boy's girlfriend her favorite gift | 9 | In the Tracker Pass |
What each of the 15 riddles of the Trial of Expression wants. The $2.99 Tracker Pass opens what each of the 32 riddles of the Trials of Resilience and Expression really asks, with the 8 fastest to pass each one marked, the moves for 3 more Sunken Echoes (7 rooms), every step of 8 later story quests, and where and when to find each critter, fish, plant and blueprint in Candy Cove and the Kingdom of Oublié, in one checklist that remembers what you have done.
One payment, no subscription. Card, Apple Pay or Google Pay. Already paid? Open the map and use "Already bought the pass".
Guardian of Boldness: Trial of Boldness
- Grotto
- Grotto of Boldness, Kingdom of Oublié.
- Opens
- The trial is the first objective of You Have to Believe (Wendy), after Forging Friendships.
- To pass
- Not confirmed yet
- All riddles
- Ruffled merfolk fin
Only 3 riddles of this trial have been reported by players so far, and the number needed to pass is not confirmed. The rest go here as soon as they are checked.
| Riddle as written | Needed | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Capture photographic evidence of an ancient coliseum. | 1 | Photograph the Throne Room in Saltwater Square: stand on the path that climbs up to it and take the shot with the building in frame. |
| Harvest a dark root vegetable. | 10 | Harvest 10 Twilight Taro, the purple root vegetable of the Kingdom of Oublié. |
| Restore the aqueduct in Saltwater Square. | 1 | Fill the Regal Coral Aqueduct blueprint: 10 Gold Sand, 5 Pink Coral (fish open water away from bubbles), 5 Blue, 3 Red and 3 Yellow Bubble Blooms. |